The Hidden Cost of Pest Control Out of Area Calls: Why 'Sorry, We Don't Service That Area’ Is Costing You Money

Written by:
Published on:
November 25, 2025

You just hung up the phone after telling another potential customer "Sorry, we don't service that area." The caller seemed disappointed, maybe even a little frustrated.

If you're a pest control operator, this probably happens 8-12 times per week. It's just part of the business, right?

Wrong. Every single one of those pest control out of area calls represents money you spent to make that phone ring and you're throwing it away.

The Real Cost Nobody Calculates

Let's break down what turning away out-of-territory calls actually costs your pest control business. Most operators never do this math, but the numbers are eye-opening.

The pest control industry generates over $26 billion annually in the US alone yet most pest control companies are unknowingly throwing away a significant portion of their marketing investment.

If you're spending $80 per lead on Google Ads and turning away 10 out-of-area calls monthly, that's $800 in wasted marketing spend. Over a year? You're looking at $9,600 in lost investment.

The Hidden Costs of Turning Away Pest Control Leads:

• $9,600 annually in wasted Google Ads spend (10 leads × $80 × 12 months)

• Lost qualified prospects who were ready to hire immediately

• Competitor advantage when customers call your competition instead

• 25% of your marketing budget generating zero return on investment based on Baton's partner report

But here's where it gets worse. Those aren't just random calls; they're qualified pest control leads who found you, called you, and were ready to hire someone. They had a pest problem and money to solve it.

Now they're calling your competitor down the road. Or worse, they're going back to Google and finding someone else entirely. Either way, you paid to generate that lead and got absolutely nothing in return.

Most pest control companies handle 15-25% of their calls this way. Think about that: one out of every four leads you pay for walks away with zero revenue to show for it. You’re turning away high-intent, valuable customers ready to pay for pest control services. 

The geographic limitations are real and nobody expects you to drive two hours for a routine treatment. But the financial impact? That's completely unnecessary.

What Industry Leaders Are Discovering

💰 $50M+ Revenue Generated for Pros

🔁 400k+ Referrals Completed

🏢 800+ Companies in Network

Smart pest control operators have figured out how to turn these "sorry, can't help" calls into exclusive pest control leads through professional referral networks.

"Every year, our inside sales department receives 2,000+ non-qualified leads and in the past, we had nowhere to send these callers other than back to a Google search. Not only does Baton Leads give us a payout for every referral we send them, but we now have a phone number to provide our non-leads with."— Alta Pest Control

This isn't about changing your business model. It's about getting paid for the marketing investment you've already made.

A Better Way: Professional Referral Networks

Here's how smart pest control companies are handling out-of-area calls now. Instead of just saying "sorry," they're turning these conversations into revenue opportunities through referrals.

When you get a call outside your service area, here's what happens:

• Your office manager says "That's outside our main service area, but I can connect you with a recommended trusted pros near your area" 

• You pass the lead through a vetted referral network to a licensed pest control operator in that area 

• The customer gets professional service from a qualified company

 • You get paid a referral fee for the connection

Let me give you a concrete example. You get a call about a termite inspection in a town 90 minutes away which is too far for your regular routes. Instead of turning it away, you refer it through the network.

A local pest control company takes the referral for $90. You earn a $45 fee. The homeowner gets their problem solved by a licensed, insured professional in their area.

That's $45 you earned from a call that would have normally generated $0. Multiply that by 10 out-of-area calls per month, and you're looking at $450 in additional monthly revenue $5,400 annually.

Compare that to your current approach: "Sorry, we don't service that area. You might try searching online." The customer hangs up frustrated, you get nothing, and someone else gets the business.

The difference isn't just financial. When you provide a helpful referral instead of a dead end, you're building your reputation as a company that goes the extra mile. That kind of service gets remembered and recommended.

This isn't some complicated system that requires training or new software. It's as simple as having a trusted network of professionals to refer to when you can't take the job yourself.

How Pest Control Companies Are Winning

Take Mike's pest control company in suburban Dallas. His service area covers about a 25-mile radius, but he regularly gets calls from 40-50 miles away which is too far to service profitably.

Before joining a referral network, Mike turned away about 12 of these calls monthly. At $150 per lead cost, that was $1,800 in wasted marketing spend every month.

Now when he gets an out-of-area call, his team refers it to vetted pest control operators in those regions. Last month alone:

• 8 termite inspection referrals = $320 in referral fees 

• 3 quarterly treatment referrals = $135 in referral fees

• 1 commercial property referral = $75 in referral fees

Total additional revenue: $530 from calls that used to generate $0.

But here's the bonus: two of those customers called back later asking if Mike's company could handle their neighbor's pest problem (which was in his service area). That generated another $400 in direct business.

The referral approach didn't just recover his marketing costs. It actually generated new business through word-of-mouth recommendations. 

Mike's not unique. Pest control companies across Texas, Florida, and California are using this same approach to turn geographic limitations into revenue opportunities.

Whether it’s ants, wasps, termites, or anything in between, Baton’s referral network makes sure every pest problem gets handled profitably.

Why Vetting Matters for Your Reputation

Here's the thing about referrals: your reputation is on the line with every one you make. When you refer someone to a customer, to some extent, the customer trusts them more now than otherwise because you pointed them in their direction. 

At Baton, we know that a service company's reputation is their most valuable asset. It isn't worth referring a customer to another company if you aren't confident that it will reflect positively on your business.

That's why we vet all our partners thoroughly according to pest control industry standards. Every pest control operator in our network are qualified companies, highly rated, committed to helping each other take care of customers and grow each other’s business. 

This isn't like throwing a customer's contact info into some online marketplace and hoping for the best. You're connecting them with professionals who've been vetted, monitored, and held accountable for maintaining your reputation.

When the customer gets great service from your referral, they remember that you made the connection. When they need pest control again, or when their neighbors ask for recommendations, your company name comes up.

Bad referrals damage relationships. Good referrals build them. Baton's vetting process ensures you're only connecting customers with operators who will reflect well on your business.

Ready to Stop Throwing Away Out-of-Area Calls?

Join our trusted referral network of over 800 pest control companies who are turning out of area pest control leads into revenue opportunities. See how Baton’s vetted referral network can help you sell pest control leads you can’t take to qualified operators in other areas. 

Baton Logo

Stay in the Loop! Get insights and opportunities, join our newsletter!

Icon
Subscription successful! Stay tuned for the latest from Baton Referrals.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.